I'm not a fan of the traditional buckles. I like the ones that click together, but with a big dog, you need to know it's gonna hold should the pooch decide to lunge.
I also don't do choke type collars, just a personal preference,
Someone on the forum, in the spring-- I believe in the TM section posted an extra wide collar, black, like a 1 1/2-- 2" wide--it was made of something that was similar to seat-belt material & was padded-Maybe it was Broccolini? The thickness is easier on the throat & also adds some better control.
At any rate, I really liked the collar & set out to find something similar. I saw some at Petco, of all places, but I was concerned the click together clasp part might not hold up, but I purchased it anyway & have been VERY happy with it.
http://www.petco.com/product/114768/Petco-Comfort-Adjustable-Purple-Dog-Collar.aspx?CoreCat=OnSiteSearch
They come in a bunch of colors. Mine was $14 & has held up quite nice for a 'cheap' collar. The online prices appear lower than the in store.
I do not have any matting issues, it does not catch her fur, & despite how thick it is, & the fact that it's purple, you barely see it even with her summer coat.
I feel better control with this collar, even though I keep it adjusted loose enough that she can slip it for most walks. I tighten it so she can't slip it for walks where there is more activity.
I do remove her collar when we are home most times.